Slipstick IV
"The Twins"
(Micky and Ricky)

A Two-stage Rocket based on parts from two Performance Rocketry G3 kits with custom ordered modifications. It is a 3" G10 airframe, about 11 feet long, and weighs 16 pounds (without reloads). The 10 lb sustainer (Micky) uses a 54mm K700W motor and the 6 lb booster (Ricky) also uses the same motor. Both sections use 48" Sphere-a-chute's for main deployment recovery. Micky has an additional PML 18" drogue chute for dual deployment. Ricky uses a Missileworks PET2 Timer for separation and an Adept ALTS 60K for apogee deployment. Micky uses another Missileworks PET2 Timer for ignition of the sustainer motor, a Missileworks RRC2X and a RRC2-mini for redundant dual deploy, and a Garmin DC20 dog tracker for recovery. Mach delay's were set at 12 seconds, at least I thought I set them to 12 seconds.

The launch was great and the flight exciting to watch, and from the ground, everything appeared to have worked as planned and in order. After the upper stage ignited and the subsequent individual pieces begin to fall as part of deployment, it became apparant that the fin can to the sustainer was missing. You can see the entire sequence of the events on the right sidebar where I zoomed in on a sequence of still photos (by Ray LaPlance and Bert Harless). The deployment charge on the sustainer's drogue chute occurred while the motor was still thrusting (going through mach). Puzzled as to the rational of the premature sparation (was it too small and too few shear pins?), I built a vacuum chamber out of a 2-1/2 gallon "Montana" jar and connected it to a vacuum cleaner to check out the altimeters. In the process I discovered the the RRC2-mini's mach delay had not been activated at all. The RRC2X is set by dip switches and was correct. the mini is set by a programmed series of button presses by watching a multi-colored led flashing. Evidently, I never set this correctly which caused the failure.

As a rocket rises the external pressure decreases and barometric altimeters look for a change in slope where the pressure starts increasing again which means the rocket is falling. However as a rocket passes through the speed of sound (or mach 1) the shock wave causes a temporary positive pressure increase around the airframe. Mach delays are used to delay the altimeters from 'looking' or reading the pressure changes until the rocket has slowed down below mach and is coasting toward apogee. Becuase this was not set correctly, the drogue was deployed at a very high speed (over 700 MPH) and the violent sparation ripped the shock cord apart. Most of the rocket came back intact, ready to fly again, but the fin can is still missing. Several NCR (Northern Colorado Rocketry) members have searched but the area needed to be broadened.

Update - June 8, 2009 - Sustainer Fin Can Found

I took advantage of the Sunday after the Pawnee Open (NAR regional Contest), because I didn't have any more rockets to launch, to look for my errant fin can off "The Twins" sustainer. Since I had numerous reports of searches that were up to the fence (1 mile to the east) I started out by parking 3 miles to the west along CR126 and hiked north 1 mile then wandered back toward the launch site. The plan was to be about a quarter mile north of the predicted track I had extended from my DC-20 GPS real track, as there was a north easterly wind that day. Then I would walk to the real track a nd follow it straight out west. My original assumption was the the fin can would maintain its trajectory, given that the momentum would keep it heading in the direction it was going at the time of separation. Assuming it was ballistic, it would have traveled the same distance and arc on the way down that it had on the way up. So the estimated location would have been twice the distance recorded on the onboard DC20 from the launch site to apogee. As it turns out, after walking 3 miles worrying the antelope to death, I crossed the fence just to get to the gps track. I almost didn't do it since others probably went there before, but just to be thorough I went a bit more further to the east. Sure enough within 100 feet of the end of the predicted track, there it was! This was another great example of having a Dc20 onboard to help locate your rocket, or in this case, rocket parts.

Unfortunately, I was now the furthest away from the truck, another 2-1/2 miles as crow flies, having to carry the fin can but I had a renewed vigor. I had carried a couple containers of water with me to help with the sorjourn, and I am glad I did. If the expiremental launches had not been canceled earlier in the day due to winds, I could have hiked a much easier distance back to the NCR site, and gotten a ride, but, alas they had all gone home. Rocksim said the fin can by itself would not have been aerodynamic, but it was obvious that it dived in the dirt nose first, shattering the airframe and kicking back about 6 feet from the hole. I picked uo all the pieces that were there. The 9V battery had even split apart! The Missile works timer was broken in half and the 10-32 all-thread studs were buckled and broken in half. The K700 motor hardware was shoved back through the retainer, popping a nice aluminum ring out of the aeropack. I pried the motor out of the fin can hoping it would still be usable, but there is nick in the end making the forward closure bind. I'll have to see if I can grip it good enough to unscrew the end and try and rework it. It looks like I'll owe Tim Lehr of Giant Leap for the motor hardware, as I don't think anyone else will want to use it.

I've ordered new parts to rebuild the sustainer's fin can, but I might be able to salvage the damaged fin can. Hey, maybe I can make a TRIPLETS three stage version????


Specifications/Design Data

Flight Path (and Search)

Total Flight Sequence
Pictures by Ray LaPlance

Build Sequence

Vacuum Chamber Altimeter Test

I made a vacuum chamber, to test the rocket controllers, using a 2-1/2 gallon "Montana" Jar from Target $19.95. After modifying the top, which has a seal in it, I connected it to my little 1.5hp shop-vac and was able to suck the insides down to an altitude of about 3200 feet elevation, indicated by a common dashboard car altimeter. A 3.25hp vac brought it to 4000 ft, but it was akward to use.

I then tested the RRC2X and RRc2 Mini, still mounted in the avbay, with 12V LEDs from Radio Shack, and they both read within 150 feet of each other, 3280 and 3165. When I let off the vacuum before 12 seconds, which is what I programmed mach delay to be, the apogee charge on the RRC2X went off only after the altimeter was less than 800 feet. I believe that is by design. However, the RRC2-mini's apogee went off as soon as apogee was detected, when I turned off the shop-vac. That wasn't right - I think.

I took the avbay apart and rechecked my settings on the RRC2-mini and I think its possible that there was no mach delay set. I was getting a long series of 10 beeps with a double chirp continuosly on that set point menu. I reset it to 12 seconds and put it back in the jar for another test.

Now when the vacumm is applied for less than 12 seconds, both of the apogee charges will not fire until the altimeter reads less than 1000 feet. The main charges fire immediatley after. If I wait more than 12 seconds, then the apogee charges fire as soon as I flip the switch off on the shop-vac. Now they are acting the same.

Root Cause: Pilot Error - The transition through Mach created a reversal in pressure and because the mach delay was not set, the RRC2-mini decided it was at apogee and fired the drogue charge. This is what caused the separation during the boost of the sustainer at high speed which created excessive forces on the shock cord system, causing the shear of the cord and the loss of fin can.

Good news: The rest of the design was OK. There is something to be said for the simplicity of the RRC2X over the mini. And...I can now functionally test my altimeters before all future flights. Yay! (anyone is welcome to come over and use my set up - beer is in the fridge).

Fin Can found on June 8, 2008 out on the prairie of the Pawnee National Grasslands

Flight Sequence

These pop up unedited so that they can be zoomed in for more detail (each about 3MB)


Copyright © 2002-2012